Anime Insider — Inside 2000s Anime Fandom

Wizard's anime magazine for the Toonami and DVD-boom era.

Anime Insider — Inside 2000s Anime Fandom

If Animerica documented anime’s arrival, Anime Insider documented its explosion. Published by Wizard Entertainment, the people behind the big comics price-guide magazines, it launched in 2001 and ran until 2009.

Its era was the boom. Toonami had been on Cartoon Network since March 1997 as a weekday afternoon block, with Dragon Ball Z and Sailor Moon among its early anime. Adult Swim followed on September 2, 2001, a Sunday night block from 10 p.m. to 1 a.m. Eastern, and Cowboy Bebop was the first anime it aired. Shonen Jump landed on US shelves in November 2002, with the first issue dated January 2003 and selling over 300,000 copies. Circulation reached 305,000 by its first anniversary.

The Toonami lineup kept moving through those years. Outlaw Star and The Big O arrived in 2001, .hack//SIGN and YuYu Hakusho in 2003, then One Piece and Naruto in 2005.

How it started

The magazine did not begin under its own name. In 2001 Wizard put out a one-shot special called Anime Invasion, followed by a run of quarterly specials from fall 2001 to fall 2002. A trademark problem with another company’s brand forced a rename. Wikipedia dates the change to April 2003.

The schedule tightened as it grew. It went bimonthly in November 2002 and monthly in July 2005. From winter 2007 the cover price was $4.99 in the US and $5.99 in Canada.

Wizard itself dated from July 1991, a comics magazine that included a price guide, and the company worked out of Congers, New York. Word bubbles added to printed pictures were a trademark of its publications.

What was in an issue

Anime Insider leaned into that fan-culture energy with previews, top-five lists, con coverage, and a louder, glossier voice than Animerica’s more editorial tone. Anime News Network’s history of Animerica quotes columnist Benjamin Wright calling it an academic magazine.

The departments had names that tell you the mood. Coming Soon and By the Numbers covered the news. Con Job reported from the conventions. Death of the Month, Top Five and Gratuitous Fanservice sat in the same news section. Readers got Animail for letters, poll results and fan art, and the staff in 2005 included Zac Betschy as part of a full-time core.

Each month a manga preview picked one upcoming English release. Trigun Maximum and Kashimashi: Girl Meets Girl were among them, and the 41st issue previewed Disgaea 2. Other sections covered DVDs, television in Japan, music charts from Oricon, video games and import reports. Flash in Japan and a Tokyo Travelogue were written by Andrez Bergen, and a JPN101 page and an Eat It, Drink It column handled daily life in Japan.

It’s peak mall-bookstore nostalgia: the magazine you grabbed next to the manga shelf to figure out what to watch next.

Rivals and the numbers

Its rivals were Viz’s Animerica, ADV’s Newtype USA and the Montreal title Protoculture Addicts. Protoculture Addicts was the elder of the group. Its test issue came out in fall 1987 in Montreal, issue 1 followed in spring 1988, and from issue 82 in 2005 it was called Anime News Network’s Protoculture Addicts. It ended with issue 97 in July and August 2008, a closure tied to the 2008 collapse of the North American anime market after Geneon USA shut down in 2007. Anime News Network later stopped regular production and hoped to continue the name as a biannual paperback.

Newtype USA started with an issue 0 at Anime Expo 2002 and a first regular issue dated November 2002. It came with a DVD, ran 65 issues by ANN’s count, and ended with the February 2008 issue. ADV tried to replace it with PiQ that March. PiQ lasted four issues and stopped in June 2008.

Circulation figures from the period disagree. In January 2005 Anime News Network gave Anime Insider upwards of 150,000 copies, ahead of Newtype USA at about 120,000 in late 2003. By January 2008 the same site was estimating Newtype USA at 50,000 to 75,000 copies a month, close to Anime Insider, and noted that no North American anime magazine published audited numbers. Wizard called its title the number one anime and manga magazine in America.

The last issue

Once Newtype USA closed, Anime Insider was cited as the English-language anime magazine with the highest distribution and sales in North America. That did not last long. On March 26, 2009, Wizard announced the end of the magazine after eight years. The editorial staff was laid off. Rob Bricken, a former editor, reported it on his blog Topless Robot. An Indonesian edition had run since 2003 and was scheduled to cease in May 2011.

Issue 67 was the last. A fan who scanned the whole run dates it to April 2009, and Anime News Network said it shipped in early March, so the date of that final issue is a few weeks fuzzy. Issue 68 had been planned, with a cover and an interview with Takashi Miike, and never appeared. Wizard’s own flagship followed in January 2011, when the print edition closed.

Animerica had already gone to a free quarterly given away in bookstores and at conventions. Newtype USA and Protoculture Addicts were gone, and so was PiQ.

Subscribe to Just another Geek

Don’t miss out on the latest issues. Sign up now to get access to the library of members-only issues.
jamie@example.com
Subscribe