Beyond Zelda — NES RPGs You Forgot Existed
The NES had a deeper RPG bench than its reputation suggests.
Everyone remembers Final Fantasy and the Zelda games, but the NES had a deeper RPG bench than its reputation suggests, and much of it came over from home computers. Final Fantasy’s own battle system drew heavily on Dungeons & Dragons and Wizardry. Here is my shelf, with release years and a few facts on each cartridge.
The computer ports
- The Ultima trilogy covers Exodus, Quest of the Avatar and Warriors of Destiny, Richard Garriott’s landmark series brought to the console. All three were published by FCI in North America, and Pony Canyon handled Exodus and Quest of the Avatar in Japan. Exodus reached the Famicom in 1987, a remake of the 1983 Apple II game, with a new soundtrack by Tsugutoshi Goto, much more dialogue and a new menu interface. Famitsu scored it 32 out of 40. Quest of the Avatar followed in Japan on September 20, 1989 and in North America in December 1990. It was squeezed onto one cartridge instead of several floppy disks, so dialogue options were cut back and the party was limited to four characters, with extras waiting at a hostel in Castle Britannia. Famitsu gave it 31 out of 40. Warriors of Destiny came in 1993, ported by Origin, and Wikipedia calls it a less faithful port than the earlier two. The intro sequences were cut, the swamp became poison fields, there are fewer music tracks, and movement is slow.
- Wizardry: Proving Grounds of the Mad Overlord is the grid-crawling dungeon RPG that shaped an entire genre, especially in Japan. Andrew Greenberg and Robert Woodhead made it for the Apple II in 1981. It is a 20 by 20 grid of mazes across ten levels with no automap, so players drew their own maps on the graph paper in the box. The Famicom version came out in Japan on December 22, 1987 and the NES version in North America in July 1990, with Nexoft publishing it. Its Japanese influence is easy to trace. Yuji Horii found Wizardry at a 1983 Apple Fest in San Francisco, borrowed the phrase “Monster surprised you!” for Dragon Quest, and wanted a Wizardry-like game on the Famicom, though a simpler one.
- Hydlide is an early action-RPG, and a real piece of history. T&E Soft released the original in Japan in December 1984 for the NEC PC-6001 and PC-8801, and its creator, Tokihiro Naito, aimed to blend action and RPG elements. The Famicom version was Hydlide Special in March 1986, and FCI brought it to North America in June 1989 as plain Hydlide. In Japan it sold about two million copies across platforms, roughly half of them on the Famicom. Its health meter, borrowed from The Black Onyx, regenerates when you stand still. North American players compared it unfavorably with The Legend of Zelda, and Electronic Gaming Monthly’s four reviewers gave it 6, 6, 5 and 5 out of 10 in 1989.
- The Magic of Scheherazade is an underrated action-RPG with a time-travel hook and party combat. Culture Brain developed it, and it hit the Famicom in Japan on September 3, 1987. Culture Brain USA announced a January 1989 North American release, which slipped to January 1990. You pick one of three classes (Fighter, Magician or Saint), recruit allies in towns, and use Time Gates to travel between past, present and future. Overworld fights are real time, while screen transitions can drop you into turn-based battles where you fight, flee or bribe. Team attacks let two party members combine for stronger magic. Famitsu scored it 27 out of 40 and Electronic Gaming Monthly 22 out of 40. Game Players gave it Best Graphics for 1989.
- Legacy of the Wizard is Falcom’s sprawling, password-driven Metroidvania-RPG. Nihon Falcom released it on the MSX2 on July 10, 1987 as Dragon Slayer IV: Drasle Family. The Famicom version arrived a week later through Namco, and Broderbund published the NES release in North America in May 1989. Five family members are playable: Xemn, Meyna, Roas, Lyll and the pet Pochi. You pick Jiela to get your password and Douel to enter one. Yuzo Koshiro and Mieko Ishikawa wrote the music. Game Developer says it is one of only three Dragon Slayer games released in the US, and describes it as huge and extremely hard. Computer Entertainer gave it 7 out of 8 stars in 1989.
The strategists
For the strategists, Koei’s Romance of the Three Kingdoms brought a deep historical war sim to a console most people associated with jumping on turtles. Koei first released it on the NEC PC-88 in 1985, and the NES version arrived in 1988. Famitsu reviewed the Famicom version in September 1988 and gave it 8, 9, 8 and 8 out of 10. Computer Gaming World’s Dave Arneson called it a great historical simulation. Nintendo Life lists it as a one-player strategy game.
Shingen the Ruler sits next to it on the shelf. It is a turn-based strategy game in which you build up forces, form alliances and fight other warlords, with random disasters such as floods and set events such as the death of Shingen’s father. It came out in Japan in August 1989 as Takeda Shingen 2, and in North America in 1990.
What the computer originals brought
Wizardry and Ultima helped inspire Dragon Quest and Final Fantasy. Game Developer calls Ultima the forefather of the main category of computer RPGs and credits it with tile-based overworlds, real towns and keyword conversations with NPCs. It describes Wizardry as a game built on scripted encounters in a grid-based dungeon, where death is common and bringing characters back costs money and can fail.
Dragon Warrior, for comparison, reached North America in August 1989. Hydlide came out that June, Legacy of the Wizard that May, and the Wizardry and Scheherazade cartridges followed in 1990.