So Bad They're Unforgettable — My NES Infamy Shelf

A collection without its disasters isn't telling the whole story.

So Bad They're Unforgettable — My NES Infamy Shelf

Not every cartridge is a treasure, but some of the worst NES games are weirdly more memorable than the good ones. My shelf has a proud infamy section, and each game on it has a paper trail.

The shelf

  • Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde came out on the Famicom in Japan on April 8, 1988, and in North America in July 1989. Advance Communication Company developed it, with Toho publishing in Japan and Bandai America in North America. Dr. Jekyll walks to his wedding church while avoiding obstacles and enemies he can’t easily attack. Damage fills an anger meter, and when it fills he turns into Mr. Hyde, who has to clear monsters in a mirrored, demonic world to change back. The Japanese and North American versions put the levels in a different order. Famitsu scored it 3, 6, 6 and 4 out of 10 at the time. Retrospective scores are lower still, with AllGame at 1.5 out of 5 and Game Informer at 0.5 out of 10. Game Informer called it flawed on every fundamental level.
  • Taboo: The Sixth Sense (North America, May 1989) was developed by Rare and published by Tradewest. Julian Jameson is listed as designer and David Wise as composer. It is barely a game at all, since it is a digital tarot-card and fortune-telling program on a cartridge. You enter your name, birth date and gender, then a question. The dealer shuffles a full 78-card deck and lays out a Celtic cross spread, and each card can come up upright or reversed. You can also pick a US state and get lottery numbers for it. It carries two warnings on the package, one for age rating and one saying it is for entertainment only.
  • Silver Surfer was released in November 1990 in the United States. Software Creations developed it and Arcadia Systems published it. Tim Follin composed the music, and IGN and GamesRadar found it highly accomplished. Den of Geek puts it first on its list of the hardest NES games and blames bullet-hell patterns plus visuals that make it hard to tell a projectile from the environment. Electronic Gaming Monthly scored it 7, 7, 6 and 7 out of 10, and Nintendo Power called it a fun and challenging action game.
  • Deadly Towers reached Japan on December 15, 1986, as Mashō, which means Evil Bell, from Irem. The Japanese cartridge had a red LED that lit when the power was on. Broderbund brought it to North America in September 1987, and Lenar developed it. You defeat seven bell-tower bosses, burn the bells and then face Rubas. Seanbaby called it the worst Nintendo game of all time in 2001, and J. C. Fletcher called it the most frustrating game on the NES in a 2007 Engadget column. Fletcher says the sword is very short and doesn’t knock enemies back, and that walking near certain walls can warp you into a shop selling items whose purpose is unclear.
  • Hydlide began on the NEC PC-6001 and PC-8801 on December 13, 1984, designed by Tokihiro Naito at T&E Soft. The NES version, Hydlide Special, came out in Japan on March 18, 1986, and FCI localized it for North America in June 1989. It sold about 2 million copies in Japan across all platforms, half of them on the Famicom. Electronic Gaming Monthly scored the NES version 5 to 6 out of 10 in 1989, and Western retrospective reception has been generally negative. It is an early action RPG and a real piece of history.
  • Bible Adventures is Wisdom Tree’s unlicensed oddity, released in 1991. Its three stories are Noah’s Ark, Baby Moses and David and Goliath. In Noah’s Ark you round up animals and food and carry them onto the ark. The other two are side-scrollers similar to Super Mario Bros. 2. The game was never sold in video game outlets, and it reportedly sold 350,000 copies in Christian bookstores. GamesRadar ranked it 68th on a list of the worst games ever made, and Seanbaby put it 19th on his list of the 20 worst.
  • Bigfoot is a monster truck racing game from Beam Software, published by Acclaim in North America in July 1990. Adam Lancman, Andrew Davie and Russell Conte designed it. Davie also programmed it, and Tania Smith composed the music. You work through events such as car crushing, mud bog, tractor pull, hill climb and drag race, and you start against a green truck called The Growler.
  • Super Pitfall came out in Japan on September 5, 1986, and in North America in November 1987, the first third-party NES game that Activision published. Micronics developed it. Items are invisible and can be grabbed only at certain moments while jumping, and Harry can jump into one enemy to warp to another part of a cave. Famicom Hisshoubon scored it 2.5, 3 and 3 out of 5, praising the maze and calling the music boring. Retro Gamer and Brett Weiss judged it inferior to the Atari 2600 Pitfall games, faulting collision detection and trial-and-error design.

Why they stay

I keep every one of them. A collection without its disasters isn’t really telling the whole story, and honestly, the bad ones spark the best conversations.

The ratings on these are not uniform. Silver Surfer’s music gets praise from IGN and GamesRadar, and Famicom Hisshoubon liked the size of the Super Pitfall maze. Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde has a cult following, which came from James Rolfe’s Angry Video Game Nerd review. Hydlide sold a million cartridges on the Famicom alone. Bible Adventures sold through a channel the rest of the NES library never used, the Christian bookstore.

Subscribe to Just another Geek

Don’t miss out on the latest issues. Sign up now to get access to the library of members-only issues.
jamie@example.com
Subscribe