Super Mario Bros. 2 — The Beautiful Mistake
Pluck a vegetable, float as Peach, and meet the oddest Mario.
Here’s a fun bit of history. The Japanese Super Mario Bros. 2 was judged too brutally hard for Western players, so Nintendo took a different game, Doki Doki Panic, reskinned it with Mario characters and shipped that as our Super Mario Bros. 2 in 1988.
Where the game came from
Nintendo of America wanted a more accessible sequel than the one Japan had. The Japanese game was later released in the West as The Lost Levels. The one we got on the NES began life as Yume Kojo: Doki Doki Panic, which came out on the Famicom Disk System on 10 July 1987. It was an advergame for Fuji TV, a promotional tie-in rather than a flagship Nintendo release.
So the American sequel was a promotional game wearing a new costume. Kensuke Tanabe directed and designed the version we know, and Shigeru Miyamoto produced it and led the design team. Koji Kondo composed the music. The North American release came on 9 October 1988, PAL regions followed in 1989, and Japan only received the American version in 1992, under the title Super Mario USA, on 14 September.
That last detail is the oddest part. Players in the West got the reskinned game in 1988, and Japan did not see it as a Mario release until 1992.
Nothing like the others
The result is the weird, wonderful black sheep of the NES Mario family. You pluck vegetables out of the ground and throw them at enemies. You pick one of four characters. Mario and Luigi are here, and so are Princess Toadstool and Toad, which made this the first Mario game in which the Princess and Toad were playable. Each handles differently. Four characters with different abilities gives each player a way to adjust the game to their own hands, which fits Nintendo of America’s wish for something more accessible. Peach floats. Luigi jumps higher than anyone, with a flutter in the air that fans call the flutter jump.
You ride magic carpets through a dream world called Subcon. The villain is Wart, a frog tyrant who rules the place. There is a Sub-space, there are warp jars, and there is a Bonus Chance minigame. It does not look like a Mario game, and it does not play like one. Everything you know about stomping enemies from the first game, you have to set aside. Here you pick them up and carry them. The vegetables you pull from the ground are the main ammunition, and the enemies themselves become projectiles once you lift them. Almost everything on screen is something to pick up and throw.
The mistake that stuck
It plays nothing like the others, and that is exactly why it is beloved. The idea of a sequel that takes a hard left is rare, and the NES era does not offer many examples. Most follow-ups to a big hit repeat what worked and add a few things. This one threw out the stomp and replaced it with a throw.
The “mistake” gave us Birdo, Shy Guys and Bob-ombs, all of which were brought into the Mario series by this game. Those characters came from Doki Doki Panic and entered the Mario world because Nintendo decided to reskin an existing game. A plan that swapped one game for another ended up adding characters to the series.
The sales numbers support the choice. The game sold 7.46 million copies worldwide, and in the US it was the top-selling game for 14 consecutive months. American players bought the substitute in huge numbers. Depending on the source, that puts it fourth or fifth among the best-selling NES games of all time. For a game that started life as a television station’s promotion, that is a long way from where it began.
Coming back to it
The game has been re-released many times. Super Mario All-Stars brought it to the Super Nintendo in 1993. BS Super Mario USA Power Challenge appeared in 1996, and Super Mario Advance followed in 2001. Each re-release puts it in front of people who never saw the original cartridge.
That is a good sign for a game that began as a stopgap. The black sheep keeps getting invited back to the family.
The characters have different abilities, the world is stranger than most, and the central action has nothing to do with the stomp that defined the first game. You can see the seams where Mario was fitted onto someone else’s design, and yet the whole thing runs as if it had always been meant to. It is a game made of borrowed parts that turned into something distinct.
The history says it was a mistake. The vegetables, the four characters and the dream world say otherwise.