Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles — That Damn Dam
Beloved, infamous, and unbeaten in a thousand living rooms.
Konami’s Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (1989) is beloved and infamous in equal measure, and the reason is two words: the dam. I will get to it. First, the game around it, because the dam gets all the blame and the rest of the cartridge deserves a fair look.
A cartoon becomes a cartridge
Konami developed the game. It reached the Famicom on 12 May 1989 and the NES in June of that year, with Ultra Games, a Konami label, publishing it in North America and Palcom handling Europe and Australia. A ZX Spectrum version followed in November 1990.
Emil Heidkamp pitched the license. The cartoon came with a catch on the audio side. The music from the TV series could not be licensed for the game, so Hidenori Maezawa, who composed and programmed the audio, wrote new tracks from scratch. If you remember the cartridge’s themes as their own thing, that is why. They had to be.
The structure was ambitious for the time. You switch between all four turtles, and each has his own reach and his own health bar. The weapons differ in speed, power and reach, so choosing who to send into a room is a real decision. You travel across an overhead map and play the levels themselves as side-scrolling stages. Pizza restores health, in whole, half and slice portions.
You start as Leonardo. Lose a turtle and he is captured, which takes him out of your rotation until you rescue him, a rule that kicks in from stage three on. So the four-turtle system is not decoration. It is a health pool you have to spend carefully, and a turtle in captivity is a turtle you cannot swap to when the one in front of you is nearly dead.
It looks great, too. Early reviews praised the graphics. Later retrospectives were harsher, and the reason is coming up.
That damn dam
Now the dam. It is the underwater level, and it asks several things of you at once. You dodge electric seaweed while you disarm bombs against a timer. Each of those would be a fair test alone. Together, in a stretch of water that punishes every wrong move, they stopped a generation of players. A generation of rented cartridges went back to the store unbeaten, and I mean that as an affectionate figure of speech and a fair description of the reputation.
The dam is brutal and a little unfair. It is also the part everybody remembers, which tells you something about how game design lodges in the brain. Nobody tells stories about the stage that went smoothly.
A level this feared by this many people has done something right, even if what it did right is make itself impossible to forget.
Why it sold
The numbers back up the memory. The game passed 1 million cartridges in the US by May 1990, and by the end of 1990 it had sold more than 4 million worldwide. Konami later reported it as the best-selling third-party NES game of 1991, a figure that comes from the company itself, so take it as Konami’s claim. Even so, the direction is plain. Lots of people bought this, and lots of them hit the dam.
The Spectrum port tells the same story from another angle. Probe made it for Image Works, and it sold 420,000 copies in its first month. The ports for the Amiga, Commodore 64 and Atari ST were reviewed worse than that one. Whatever else you say about the original, it traveled.
The game also had a long tail. It was followed by a 1989 arcade game, then Turtles in Time in 1991, The Manhattan Project in 1991 and The Hyperstone Heist in 1992. Those games came after this one and had its audience waiting for them.
The cartridge that came first
For a lot of us it was the first TMNT game we owned. That matters more than any review score. The cartoon was everywhere, and here was a version of it you could hold in your hands and plug into the console. The cartoon-to-cartridge magic outweighed the rage. Mostly.
That “mostly” carries a lot of weight. You can love a game and still resent a single level, and the Turtles cartridge is the clearest example I know. The overhead map is fun. The turtle swapping is clever. The music Maezawa wrote under a licensing restriction still holds up as game music. And then there is a timer, some seaweed and a pile of bombs.
I think that is why the game survives as more than a punchline. It was ambitious, and the ambition cost something. A smaller, safer game would have been forgotten by now. This one is remembered because it asked for more than most NES games dared to, and because one of its levels asked for too much. Both things are true at the same time.
The dam is still down there, waiting.