Tetris — The Game and the Lawsuit
The version we grew up on, and the legal thriller behind it.
The NES Tetris from 1989 is the version most Americans grew up on, but its backstory reads like a legal thriller. Nintendo’s cartridge came out in North America in November 1989. Europe followed on 23 February 1990. It was built by Nintendo R&D1, and Alexey Pajitnov, who gets credit for the original concept, design and program, was not involved in this version. Howard Phillips picked the color palettes, according to the Video Game History Foundation.
I keep the Nintendo cart. The Tengen one is the white whale.
Who owned Tetris
The rights were a tangle. Pajitnov made the game in the mid-1980s in Moscow. The Soviet licensing body, Elorg, first licensed it to Robert Stein for computers only. From there, sublicenses spread: Mirrorsoft in Europe, Spectrum HoloByte in North America, Bullet-Proof Software in Japan. One account says that by 1989 about six companies claimed rights to Tetris software.
Bullet-Proof, run by Henk Rogers, put Tetris on the Famicom in December 1988. It sold about two million copies in Japan, and Elorg did not know the cartridge existed. In February 1989 Rogers flew to the Soviet Union, negotiated with Elorg directly, and paid over $40,000 to fix the breach. Elorg then gave Nintendo both the handheld and console rights.
Atari Games held an arcade license and nothing for consoles. Its subsidiary Tengen went ahead anyway.
The Tengen version
Tengen shipped its NES Tetris on 17 May 1989, titled Tetris: The Soviet Mind Game. It was not a port of the arcade game. Designer Ed Logg said in a 1999 interview that he rebuilt it from scratch for the NES. The pieces started out black and white, and Logg colorized them at the request of Tengen’s president, Randy Broweleit.
It also had more in it than Nintendo’s cart. It offered simultaneous two-player play where both players get the same piece sequence, a co-op mode on a single shared field (12 columns wide instead of 10), and modes against or with a computer player. Tengen’s cartridges came in black shells with reversed labels, typical of its unlicensed games. Logg also said Nintendo’s version “wasn’t tuned right” because its speed curve lacked logarithmic adjustment, so the difficulty jumped too steeply.
The court calendar
The dates, as I read them:
- 31 March 1989: Howard Lincoln of Nintendo of America faxed a cease-and-desist letter to Atari Games.
- April 1989: Tengen sued Nintendo, and Nintendo countersued.
- 22 June 1989: Judge Fern M. Smith of the US District Court in Northern California granted a preliminary injunction against Atari Games. The court had rejected Atari’s argument that the NES counted as a “computer” under the original contract.
- 23 June 1989: Atari withdrew its NES version.
- 13 November 1989: Smith granted summary judgment to Nintendo, giving it the console rights.
Tengen’s cartridge was on shelves for about four weeks. The numbers disagree on how much was sold and destroyed. One source puts sales at roughly 100,000 copies by the time of the court order, another says fewer than that, and a separate figure has 268,000 cartridges recalled and destroyed. Thousands of unsold copies stayed in the warehouse, and surviving cartridges later sold for as much as $300.
A separate, larger fight between the two companies ran through the early 1990s. That one was about Nintendo’s 10NES lockout chip. The Federal Circuit decided it on 10 September 1992, and it had nothing to do with Tetris itself. Tengen was folded into Time Warner Interactive after Atari settled in 1994.
What Nintendo’s cartridge plays like
Nintendo’s NES Tetris is a one-player game. The field is 10 by 20. There is no hold piece, no hard drop, and no wall kicks. Gravity begins at 48 frames per row on level 00 and drops to a single frame per row at level 29. Type A and Type B are the two modes, and this is the cartridge used for the Classic Tetris World Championship.
The music on this cartridge is not what many people expect. The tune everyone hums, Korobeiniki, belongs to the Game Boy version. The NES cart plays arrangements of the Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy from Tchaikovsky’s The Nutcracker and the overture to Bizet’s Carmen, with the soundtrack leaning on Russian classical music. Nintendo’s NES version swapped Korobeiniki out.
The NES has no hardware random number support, so the game works out piece order with a 16-bit linear-feedback shift register, a small piece of code that shuffles bits to fake chance.
How it sold and how people judged it
Nintendo’s version sold three million copies fast and sat on Nintendo’s most-popular list for over a year. Another account says it moved 1.5 million in its first six months, worth $52 million. By 2004 the total reached 8 million worldwide, according to a BBC documentary.
Reviewers split on which cartridge was better. IGN said almost everyone regarded Nintendo’s version as inferior to Atari’s, and it ranked the Tengen game 48th on its Top 100 NES list while leaving Nintendo’s off. Electronic Gaming Monthly called the Atari version “more playable and in-depth.” Computer Entertainer recommended the Nintendo cartridge only to players who had not tried Atari’s. The AllGame review gave the Nintendo cart 4.5 out of 5.